Title: The Swallow
First Non-Festival Release: TBD
Director: Kevin Kölsch, Dennis Widmyer
Writer: Kevin Kölsch, Dennis Widmyer
Runtime: 82 Minutes
Starring: Grace Van Dien, Brittany Allen, Madeleine Coghlan
Where to Watch: Check out where to find it here
This film’s review was written after its screening at the Fantastic Film Festival in 2026.
Many horror films feature casts of hot, obnoxious 20-year-olds causing trouble and paying for it later. Some people find excitement, humor, and downright glee at the thought of them dying onscreen. There’s a certain schadenfreude many viewers have in seeing, to them, genuinely annoying, evil, or just sort of mean people getting their “just desserts.” Others find the practice irritating because it makes it harder to take the film seriously. Without any kind of anchor for audiences to attach themselves to, can you blame them if they start cheering on the killer mud?
Five young adults, Ziggy (Grace Van Dien), Ziggy’s boyfriend Vince (Kalama Epstein), Rich (Jack Wright), Rich’s girlfriend Katie (Tayler Buck), and Katie’s little sister Kim (Kayla DiVenere) take a road trip to the woods. Rich wants to take the group camping at a nostalgic spot from his childhood. When they arrive, they find that the woods have been blocked by a sprawling chain link fence armed with barbed wire. Undeterred, the group finds a hole and slides through it. They quickly get to work setting up camp and enjoying themselves. Their picturesque weekend adventure sours quickly when they realize that they are not alone in the forest.
A plodding survival horror, The Swallow lacks the finesse needed to pull off its genuinely interesting premise.
Rushing through unimportant things like character development or tension building, The Swallow makes one baffling choice after another the farther along it gets into its runtime. Characters are assigned vague personalities that are flexible when danger strikes. Lacking in substantial backstory, unique traits, or interesting dialogue, the young adults meander around the woods before two almost immediately get stuck in the mud. Once the horror arrives, it stops. Lacking any urgency, the characters saunter around the woods aimlessly, barely use any of the resources at their disposal (minus the capable final girl, of course), and just generally suck the life out of the film with their petty squabbles and melodrama.
What once created an air of mystery becomes a silly game of predicting what stupid choice a character will make next. There should be some degree of understanding and grace given to horror film characters. They don’t know they are in a horror film. This stance is hard to defend when films like The Swallow repeatedly have their characters split up, argue, or even fall for psychological tricks from the mud. While demonstrating the source of danger is on the ground, for some reason there are very few shots of the characters ever engaging with the ground in a way that makes it feel a part of their universe.
It doesn’t help that The Swallow isn’t concerned with consistency either. It’s okay that there is never an answer to why exactly the mud behaving this way. Is it a creature? Is it radioactive? It is Mother Nature fighting back? Who knows; who cares? Those are questions that can be answered if the writer decides it is important. What is important, however, is that the writer knows the answer to these questions so the mechanics of their villain can be understood. The mud in The Swallow behaves in whatever way makes the characters move between the limited set pieces.
Looking at the mud itself, it appears very tactile and moves with intentionality, one of the better elements of the film. It also leads to some pretty horrific death sequences too. The tension that is missing from the first two acts suddenly kick starts right as the film ends.
The best that can be said about The Swallow is that it coasts on its production values, even if they aren’t all great at that. It’s decently shot, utilizing some cool vertical angles to depict the swallowing whole of the various young adults. As mentioned, the mud effects are surprisingly well-done, especially towards the end when it expands a bit in scope. Its cast is fine, even if their characters aren’t and the set design works, even if it is minimal.
Despite its attempts to spice up to the classic Creepshow 2 segment, “The Raft”, The Swallow sinks to the bottom of the mud pit with its insipid approach to survival horror. Bland characters, dull storytelling, and baffling decisions make it hard to appreciate the genuinely strong technical elements and cool concept. Without a solid performance or signature scene to attach to, The Swallow ends up a perfectly middling high concept horror film that disappoints and exasperates more than it scares.
Overall Score? 5/10